BRIAN HAZEL, SOUTH & ASSOCIATES. HERE IS WHY YOU SUCK.
Brian Hazel, you aren't nice, you are aren't swell (except your head might be), and you aren't doing a good job. You are STEALING homes. That is ALL you know how to do. Obviously.
by Kelly L. Hansen
Brian, your firm, South & Associates (S & A) is a law firm that specializes as a foreclosure mill in my home State of Kansas. You've WON AWARDS for stealing homes. You have offices nationwide. S & A produces questionable assignments, alters documents, willingly notarizes and commits forgeries willy-nilly. I think many of your associates just like to sign their names to prove they can. And I think the ones that don't want to commit acts of forgery for fear their law licenses may be revoked, are often forced to, by you, to keep their jobs.
Your Associates often sign on behalf of Mortgage Electronic Registration Systems, Inc. (MERS) as a Secretary or Vice President of MERS as a nominee (as per MERS mortgage contracts) of one of your Bank or Mortgage clients. Did you know this is an illegal act? Did you know that any homeowner losing their home due to an illegal act by S & A could sue you and get their home back? (Of course you do. This is for the benefit of my readers.)
They could simply go to their county recorder -- check to see if a correct chain of title exists. When MERS is involved a correct chain of title is questionable, at best. The homeowner should file a Motion for Loss of Subject Matter Jurisdiction Over the Case (based upon fraud upon the Court.) Robo-signing, forgery, failure to perfect a lien, false witness on assignment,
Buddy up with Darren and Becky Volk to help you out just a little bit more and see where it will get you. Because I LOOK FORWARD to the challenge of searching high and low to see what else I can come up with, what other little dirty secrets I can find out about both you and Apple Assets in this State's, and in other State's Court records, to take you both down. Believe me, I'm not the only one looking. Because I am M-O-T-I-V-A-T-E--D to see dirty little swine corporations such as yours be made unmentionable, horrific words on the lips of every homeowner I meet. Ask Darren Volk just why. And if he won't tell you, Becky will. And if she won't, they know, I WILL.
They stole my home. Steve Six started to shut them down, but didn't finish the job he started. Apple Assets should not be in business. They are bad people. You are no better.
The Volks have children, and that is the only reason I don't come down on them any harder than I currently do. If they are smart, they will stay away. I know some of the people at your firm are good people, because even among swine, are good people. However, Brian, do not provoke me, or make me angrier, by making more stupid comments like the comments made on my MERS blog yesterday.
You are not funny. This is not funny. Stealing homes is not funny. Go to Church. Say some prayers. Today has been a shitty day. Perhaps I could have handled this better, but I am pissed. Sue me. You asshole.
Thursday, June 7, 2012
Monday, January 30, 2012
MATT TABBI'S THOUGHTS ON THE FORECLOSURE SETTLEMENT'S PROGRESS
by Matt Tabbi, Rolling Stone
So there was big news yesterday on the foreclosure settlement front. We still have to wait and see what the final deal looks like, but there are reports out that the long-awaited settlement is a far, far better deal for the public than expected. If these reports are true, it looks like New York Attorney General Eric Schneiderman and California AG Kamala Harris have scored an enormous victory in narrowing the scope of the settlement to the point where it really only covers robosigning abuses.
I'm interested to see what the market reaction will be if this deal goes through. On the one hand the banks will all obtain some certaintly and relief from robosigning claims. But on the other hand, all the banks are still on the hook in other areas, nost notably putbacks of bad loans.
Robosigning had a profound and immediate impact on large numbers of actual human beings, and I don't want people to think I'm dismissing it as unimportant. I probably also shouldn't celebrate news like this until I see how the actual deal looks, what wording is used to narrow the deal's purview, how homeowners and other victims will be compensated, what will be done to prevent it in the future, and so on.
But my point was that, while a gross crime and one of the more obvious (and easily provable) parts of the criminal scheme common during the mortgage bubble years, robosigning is really an ancillary part of an even more enormous fraud that went on, and is still going on, in securitization/origination. Many homeowners were victimized by robosigning, but your more common victim of bank fraud during this time was an investor in MBS -- maybe even another WallStreet entity like a hedge fund or a bond insurer, maybe a foreign trade union, maybe a state worker whose pension fund lost 40% of its value because it was sold bad bonds by a too-big-to-fail bank. And the hook that snared those victims was securitization.
When I first heard about the foreclosure settlement, I thought it might contain a broad waiver for everything, including the tax evasion issues, the fair lending issues, securitization, and all the other things on that list above. If they did that, that would be TARPx10. My only point about this deal is that it appears to have been effectively negotiated down from a bloocurdling outrage to whatever it is now, which is probably something far less than that: it may still be a serious underpay, but it's not the unreal, criminal giveaway it was originally meant to be.
And it still leaves plenty of room for criminal investigation and reform. The people who organized and supervised the robosigning could and should still be targets of criminal prosecution, deal or no deal: this won't change that.
All I'm saying is, good for Schneiderman/Harris for holding out and preventing this settlement from being another AIG -- a secret backroom bailout in which everybody at the table got the government to solve their balance sheet problems in 24-48 hours of frenzied, disorganized discussion. This is still a bailout, but at the very least, someone represented the public this time around.
We still have to see what it looks like in the end, but I'm encouraged.
I talked more on this with the excellent Bill Press on Countdown last night:
So there was big news yesterday on the foreclosure settlement front. We still have to wait and see what the final deal looks like, but there are reports out that the long-awaited settlement is a far, far better deal for the public than expected. If these reports are true, it looks like New York Attorney General Eric Schneiderman and California AG Kamala Harris have scored an enormous victory in narrowing the scope of the settlement to the point where it really only covers robosigning abuses.
According to reports (like this one in the Huffington Post), the deal will not include:
If that is true, and all of those things are out of the deal, and the banks are still exposed to liability not only for all of those things, but also for the broad range of offenses related to securitization, then $25 billion, dare I say it, might not even be a completely sucky number. It's far less than the real liability, but it's a much bigger sum than I ever thought would be negotiated just for robosigning.
- Criminal liability.
- Tax liability
- Fair lending, fair housing, or any other civil rights claim.
- Federal Housing Finance Agency or the GSEs [Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac]
- CFPB claims for the period after they came into existence in July 2011
- SEC claims
- National Credit Union Association Claims
- FDIC claims
- Federal Reserve Board claims
- MERS claims
I'm interested to see what the market reaction will be if this deal goes through. On the one hand the banks will all obtain some certaintly and relief from robosigning claims. But on the other hand, all the banks are still on the hook in other areas, nost notably putbacks of bad loans.
Score one for Schneiderman/Harris. Coupled with the news that the subpoenas have already started dropping on the securitization front, I'm almost optimistic.
p.s. let me clarify something, for readers who might mistake my meaning here. Robosigning is not a small offense. It's not a "clerical" issue. It's a mass-perjury issue, a tax evasion issue, a contractual fraud issue, and it's a criminal conspiracy issue (the banks' highest executives were engaged in planning it) and it resulted in millions of errors that resulted in untold numbers of premature foreclosures.Robosigning had a profound and immediate impact on large numbers of actual human beings, and I don't want people to think I'm dismissing it as unimportant. I probably also shouldn't celebrate news like this until I see how the actual deal looks, what wording is used to narrow the deal's purview, how homeowners and other victims will be compensated, what will be done to prevent it in the future, and so on.
But my point was that, while a gross crime and one of the more obvious (and easily provable) parts of the criminal scheme common during the mortgage bubble years, robosigning is really an ancillary part of an even more enormous fraud that went on, and is still going on, in securitization/origination. Many homeowners were victimized by robosigning, but your more common victim of bank fraud during this time was an investor in MBS -- maybe even another WallStreet entity like a hedge fund or a bond insurer, maybe a foreign trade union, maybe a state worker whose pension fund lost 40% of its value because it was sold bad bonds by a too-big-to-fail bank. And the hook that snared those victims was securitization.
When I first heard about the foreclosure settlement, I thought it might contain a broad waiver for everything, including the tax evasion issues, the fair lending issues, securitization, and all the other things on that list above. If they did that, that would be TARPx10. My only point about this deal is that it appears to have been effectively negotiated down from a bloocurdling outrage to whatever it is now, which is probably something far less than that: it may still be a serious underpay, but it's not the unreal, criminal giveaway it was originally meant to be.
And it still leaves plenty of room for criminal investigation and reform. The people who organized and supervised the robosigning could and should still be targets of criminal prosecution, deal or no deal: this won't change that.
All I'm saying is, good for Schneiderman/Harris for holding out and preventing this settlement from being another AIG -- a secret backroom bailout in which everybody at the table got the government to solve their balance sheet problems in 24-48 hours of frenzied, disorganized discussion. This is still a bailout, but at the very least, someone represented the public this time around.
We still have to see what it looks like in the end, but I'm encouraged.
I talked more on this with the excellent Bill Press on Countdown last night:
Prev
| Taibblog Main |
- MOVIES & TV Peter Travers Rages Against Oscars Snubs
More From Rolling Stone
From Around the Web
Friday, December 30, 2011
WELL NOW, THE NEVADA SUPREME COURT IS ABOUT TO MAKE THINGS INTERESTING! ANYBODY WANT TO GUESS WHICH WAY THIS ONE IS GOING TO GO?
Nevada Supreme Court to Hear Case to Determine Legality of MERS Foreclosures
By Michael Kraus on December 29, 2011

Nevada’s real estate market was devastated by the bursting real estate bubble and the subsequent foreclosure crisis. Home prices in many areas of Nevada are down by 50-60% or more since the market peaked in 2006. Until recently, Nevada has consistently had one of the highest rates of foreclosure in the country.
Now, the Nevada State Supreme Court is set to hear a case that may consider whether or not the Mortgage Electronic Registration System (MERS) has the right to foreclose on a property in its own name. If the State Supreme Court rules that mortgages assigned by MERS cannot establish ownership, homeowners could challenge any foreclosure done in MERS’ name. Other courts across the country are split on this issue.
MERS holds more than half of mortgages across the United States, and a similar number in Nevada. MERS has been at the center of much controversy over the past couple of years, and was recently the focus of a scathing piece in Harper’s Magazine (Stop Payment! A Homeowner’s Revolt Against the Banks), as well as an investigative report on 60 Minutes.
The housing market in Nevada is so bad, that according to Corelogic’s 3rd Quarter Negative Equity Report, as of November, 58.3% of homes with mortgages in Nevada are underwater, while 4.8% have near negative equity. Total home equity in Nevada among homeowners with mortgages is less than -$10.3 billion, making the average loan-to-value ratio in the state 110.2%. Nevada is the only state that has a net negative home equity.
As a result of this disaster, Nevada has been one of the most aggressive states in fighting mortgage abuses. In October, Nevada passed a tough anti-foreclosure law that makes it a felony for a lender, servicer or trustee to make false representations or claims over a title. In the wake of this law, foreclosures in Nevada plummeted.
Nevada Attorney General Catherine Cortez Masto has been very aggressive in fighting foreclosure fraud and robo-signing. Notably, she is pursuing criminal charges against robo-signers, has teamed with California Attorney General Kamala Harris in a joint investigation into mortgage abuses, and recently announced a suit against Lender Processing Services for consumer fraud in their foreclosure practices in Nevada.
This case could have a massive impact to say the least. I will be following this one closely and will report back with updates.
Wednesday, December 28, 2011
DID YOU LOSE YOUR HOME TO WRONGFUL FORECLOSURE? HERE IS HOPE.
HOMEOWNERS: DID YOU LOSE YOUR HOME TO WRONGFUL FORECLOSURE? DO YOU BELIEVE YOU HAVE A ROBO-SIGNATURE ON YOUR DOCUMENTS?
If you lost your house in foreclosure or were forced to short sale it because your lender would not work with you... don't give up just yet. If you have a robo-signature by your bank on your loan or a lack of proper paperwork regarding transfer of title by your bank... you definitely have legal options to go after your lender for a wrongful foreclosure.
Do any of you feel that you were wrongfully foreclosed upon, and what is your story?
You can call me (Andrew) at 877-400-0219 ext. 301, I can go over exactly what I am talking about and your options. I look forward to speaking with you and hearing your story.
Or if your prefer, e-mail Andrew the details of your story. Send him your home's address, city, state, county, the name the title was in, and your phone number.
GOD BLESS YOU ANDREW!
If you lost your house in foreclosure or were forced to short sale it because your lender would not work with you... don't give up just yet. If you have a robo-signature by your bank on your loan or a lack of proper paperwork regarding transfer of title by your bank... you definitely have legal options to go after your lender for a wrongful foreclosure.
Do any of you feel that you were wrongfully foreclosed upon, and what is your story?
You can call me (Andrew) at 877-400-0219 ext. 301, I can go over exactly what I am talking about and your options. I look forward to speaking with you and hearing your story.
Or if your prefer, e-mail Andrew the details of your story. Send him your home's address, city, state, county, the name the title was in, and your phone number.
GOD BLESS YOU ANDREW!
Friday, October 28, 2011
WHAT ABOUT HOMEOWNER HOSKING? WAKE UP AG KAMALA HARRIS AND DOBERMAN MITCHELL J. STEIN AND HELP VIRGINIA HOSKING WHO IS SCARED OUT OF HER MIND, WAITING TO BE FORCED FROM HER HOME. FOCUS!
Lawyer accused of mortgage-related fraud sues attorney general
October 28, 2011 | Will Evans
Jeff Turner/FlickrLos Angeles-area attorney Mitchell J. Stein refers to himself as "The Doberman" and his website advertises, "You Hold The Leash."
In August, California Attorney General Kamala Harris raided Stein's offices and accused him and other lawyers of fraudulently misleading thousands of struggling homeowners into paying to be part of mass lawsuits against mortgage lenders like Bank of America.
But Stein sued back, after warning on his Twitteraccount that "The Doberman is about to take a large bite out of Kamala Harris." Stein has accused the attorney general of being "the pawn of America’s most powerful banks,” claiming that Bank of America "corruptly funneled money" to Harris, according to one of his lawsuits.
As the legal sparring continues, the alleged fraud victims are running out of time.
Virginia Hosking received a notice last week directing her to vacate her foreclosed Whittier house within three days.
Related
Report an error: See something wrong in this story?
E-mail our editors.Hosking said her husband had just passed away and she was facing foreclosure last year when she paid $4,000 to another law firm targeted in Harris' fraud suit.
Hosking said she was told that joining the lawsuit against her mortgage lender, Bank of America, would help save her house. At some point, Stein's firm, which has been suing Bank of America since 2009, took charge of Hosking's case.
The attorney general accused the lawyers of deceiving homeowners into thinking that the lawsuits would stop foreclosures or reduce their mortgage payments. In a press conference announcing the action, Harris called it "work that will bring justice to many homeowners in California who were targeted by predators who happened to have a law license."
Stein, who signs e-mails with a picture of a Doberman pinscher, claims that he is "Bank of America’s biggest nightmare" and that Harris' suit puts struggling homeowners at risk.
He points out that Harris received four donations in February, totaling $1,500, from attorneys with the law firm representing Bank of America.
Stein's recent lawsuit accuses Harris of doing the bidding of Bank of America by removing "the superstar who had been beating the bank to a pulp for two and a half years."
Shum Preston, a spokesman for Harris, called the suit frivolous.
"We respectfully decline to address the very strange claims made in this lawsuit," he said in a statement. "It is, sadly, another example of what we uncovered during our investigations: false promises designed to lure already distressed homeowners into paying money to lawyers who refuse to properly represent them."
A Bank of America spokeswoman declined to comment.
Stein's office sent e-mails to clients like Hosking asking them to show up at a court hearing to support Stein "in the fight against bank and government corruption."
His firm sent out a press release that said hundreds of homeowners would gather in solidarity with the Occupy Wall Street movement and "against Ms. Harris' support of the 1%."
Meanwhile, the State Bar of California obtained a court order stating that Stein "has become incapable of devoting the time and attention to ... his law practice" and authorizing the bar to seize his files and freeze his bank accounts.
Stein, however, maintains the order doesn't apply because it names Mitchell J. Stein and Associates and not his newer partnership, Mitchell J. Stein & Associates LLP. For the same reason, Stein's website states, "this law Firm has never been sued by the State of California."
Stein is also trying to stop seizure of his assets through his Florida bankruptcy proceeding.
The state bar notified Hosking that she could pick up the confiscated files relating to her, but she would have to find another lawyer.
Hosking keeps getting solicitations promising to save her house if she pays a fee.
"There are all kinds of preying people out there. I don’t know who to trust anymore," she said.
The state bar will work to return money to alleged victims from Stein's frozen funds, said Suzan Anderson, an attorney for the bar. Authorities also are encouraging banks to give a break to people like Hosking.
"Right now, the attorney general and the state bar are discussing with the lenders how they might be able to put a hold on any foreclosures because of these actions and maybe work with the people and give them time," Anderson said.
Related articles
- Companies sued for calling bottles biodegradable (sfgate.com)
- Cali Attorney General Asks Feds To Chill Out (hailmaryjane.com)
- Judge enjoins Calif. lawyers accused in bank suits (seattletimes.nwsource.com)
- State sues lawyers (manifestinjustice.wordpress.com)
- Judge Won't Interfere With Cops' Gun Savvy(CA) (gunnyg.wordpress.com)
- California Attorney General Kamala Harris 'Acted as the Pawn of America's Most... - LOS ANGELES, Sept. 6, 2011 /PRNewswire/ - (lesliebrodie.wordpress.com)
- APNewsBreak: Lawyers accused of scam in bank suits (seattletimes.nwsource.com)
- Lawyer who was accused of fraud by California fires back (huffingtonpost.com)
- State Attorney General Accuses 'Biodegradable' Water Bottle Makers of Greenwashing (laist.com)
- Morgan Stanley Downgrades Bank of America, Bank of America Rallies (blogs.wsj.com)
Saturday, October 15, 2011
SAN MATEO BOARD OF SUPERVISORS ARE RESOLVED TO STEP IN FILL THE GAP THE GOVERNMENT HAS LEFT AND COMMUNICATE TO THE FEARS OF HOMEOWNERS
Foreclosures rise in San Mateo County;
local officials try to help
By Stephanie Soderborg | 15 Oct 2011
Like an obnoxious neighbor, housing problems did not wait for Rose Jacobs Gibson to settle in to her position on the San Mateo County Board of Supervisors before they came calling. Her first two days in office, she remembers, the phone lines were flooded by elderly and low-income constituents who feared they would lose their homes because of changes to the federal Section 8 subsidy program.

Crowds wait in line to check in to the Oct. 1 San Mateo Count Foreclosure Resource Fair. (Photo: Stephanie Soderborg/Peninsula Press)
People did not understand how the changes would affect their lives, and the government was not doing enough to inform them, Jacobs Gibson decided. She resolved to help get the necessary information to the public.
Twelve years later, her cause remains the same – only now her work focuses largely on the thousands of home foreclosures in the county.
Early this month, her office hosted a Foreclosure Resource Fair, bringing together bank lenders, housing counselors and legal advisers to provide free advice to the nearly 200 people who crowded into a community center in Menlo Park. At the fair, the supervisor’s office began to distribute a 28-page guide for homeowners and renters, titled “Foreclosure Prevention.”
The guide provides answers to frequently asked questions, offers tips for avoiding foreclosure, suggests when not to keep a home and lists more than 60 local foreclosure assistance resources. Those resources include counseling agencies, alternative housing resources, legal aid and nonprofits that provide related services such as mental health counseling and food programs.
“One of the challenges is that people have such pride, and when it comes to their home it is just so difficult to have to admit that you are faced with whatever the problem is,” Jacobs Gibson said.

Supervisor Rose Jacobs Gibson addresses the attendants of the 2011 Foreclosure Resource Fair. (Photo: Stephanie Soderborg/Peninsula Press)
As measured by per capita figures, San Mateo County has weathered the nation’s foreclosure crisis better than many areas of California. Of late, though, the trend is more ominous. In September, 788 properties were under notice of default, forced auction or bank repossession in the county, up from 498 in August, according to RealtyTrac.com, which tracks foreclosures. Counties in the rest of the Bay Area saw a decrease over the same month.
Foreclosures can have a widespread effect on a community by depressing property values.
Encouraging homeowners to seek help is an important step, Jacobs Gibson said. Residents who work with housing counselors are 60 percent more likely to keep their homes and significantly modify their loans than those who do not seek help, according to an Urban Institute study.
“A lot of homeowners feel that they have to come up with money to seek help, which they don’t. Some feel that they can resolve the problem themselves, when they cannot,” said Bob Kane, a lawyer who volunteers at the free Community Legal Service in East Palo Alto. “For a lot of them it is just that they are not aware of the resources out there.”
Many people who attended the Oct. 1 resource fair agreed to be interviewed under the condition that they be identified by first name only, explaining that the forced loss of a home is a highly personal matter.
A homeowner named Jeff said he drove 90 minutes one way to attend the fair. Due to lack of counseling, he said, he did not recognize the severity of his situation until too late. Now he is facing foreclosure. “I thought we had a minor bump in the road,” he said.
The fair and resource guide also help governments and community service agencies because, in some cases, not everyone is aware of where to refer clients, according to Jacobs Gibson.
Martin Eichner, the director of Project Sentinel, a HUD counseling center, said large agencies coordinate with each other already. But until now, Jacobs Gibson said, it was hard to find a single resource listing all the available services. “There will be a little more assistance now that people can provide with out having to try and think, ‘who do I call and where do I go,’” she said.
Laura Fanucchi, the associate director of Human Investment Project Housing, a nonprofit dedicated to home sharing and self-sufficiency, explained another benefit of the resource guide: “We cannot focus our time on creating this type of resource, yet it is so valuable in case management.”
Agencies that provide assistance to the best of their abilities bring peace of mind to many struggling clients. For Jeff, the counseling advice he received at the resource fair provided a sense of relief.
“We came in scared to death… at the potential of loosing our house at some unknown date in some unknown process,” he said. “We are able to come out today… and we’re pleased. We are coming out happy.”
You may also like -
Related articles
- Foreclosure Blues: San Mateo County Dangerously Close to a Foreclosure Crisis (sf.curbed.com)
- AM Linkage: Oakland Pot Dispensary Needs to Pay Up; McMansions and Affordable Housing; New Jail Coming to San Mateo County; More! (sf.curbed.com)
- Toyota 101 Proudly Announces the Debut of the 2012 Toyota Camry (prweb.com)
- Police Who Illegally Broke Into Gizmodo Journalist's House Deride Seized E-mails as "Juvenile" (eff.org)
- Man arrested for peeping at San Mateo 24 Hour Fitness center (mercurynews.com)
- Peninsula Open Space Trust Sells Pillar Point Bluff To San Mateo County (naturalhistorywanderings.com)
- Sharp Park: The best solution to do nothing (sfgate.com)
- The best solution for Sharp Park is to do nothing (sfgate.com)
- Sellers of Lost iPhone 4 Prototype Get Probation (online.wsj.com)
- San Mateo REALTOR Herb Schmulewicz Offers Four Tips for Short Sale and Foreclosure Home Buying (prweb.com)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
DO YOU NEED HELP TO AVOID FORECLOSURE?
If you would like to receive information on how you might avoid the foreclosure of your home, please e-mail me your name, address, and phone number. Someone from our office will be in touch right away to assist you.
With Warm Regards,
Kelly L. Hansen,
HOMEOWNERS HELPING HOMEOWNERS,
ctsmyhon@yahoo.com
Be happy, healthy and prosperous, but most of all, be blessed. 
Kelly L. Hansen
Jurisdictionary® just click on the link
Make Sure Your Attorney Is Working For You!
Kelly L. Hansen
HOMEOWNERS HELPING HOMEOWNERS FOUNDATION
33605 W. 88th Street
De Soto, KS 66018
913-269-0399 Phone
888-881-2349 Fax
MORTGAGE FRAUD VICTIMS
ARE YOU A VICTIM OF MORTGAGE FRAUD?
PLEASE DONATE TO HELP HOMEOWNERS!

Kelly L. Hansen
Jurisdictionary® just click on the link
Make Sure Your Attorney Is Working For You!
Kelly L. Hansen
HOMEOWNERS HELPING HOMEOWNERS FOUNDATION
33605 W. 88th Street
De Soto, KS 66018
913-269-0399 Phone
888-881-2349 Fax
MORTGAGE FRAUD VICTIMS
ARE YOU A VICTIM OF MORTGAGE FRAUD?
PLEASE DONATE TO HELP HOMEOWNERS!







While interest rates have never been more attractive, the number of people taking advantage of the historically low rates and refinancing their mortgages has dropped substantially, most of them dont even aware of the rates, i recommend 123 Refinance for refinance
Criminal liability.
Tax liability
Fair lending, fair housing, or any other civil rights claim.
Federal Housing Finance Agency or the GSEs [Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac]
Since 1996 bac has sold 94% of their mortgages to fnma. If 94% are left out of settlement...................what is being settled?
Criminal liability.
Tax liability
Fair lending, fair housing, or any other civil rights claim.
Federal Housing Finance Agency or the GSEs [Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac]
As far back as 1996, bac sold 94% of all their mortgages to fnma. If 94% are left out of settlement...................................what is being settled???????????
Refinancing to a shorter mortgage term may allow you to build your home equity and pay off your mortgage faster. You can easily find your rates from websites like 123 Refinance in secs
Good job with the interview. I agree with your assessment of Press as excellent. When it comes to Obama, however, I hope you heed the words (more or less) of George W. Bush. "Fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice, shame on me. Won't get fooled again!" (I'm sure you don't intend the piece as an election piece, but coming in an election year, it will inevitably be interpreted that way.)
a) The monitor must have the ability to access and review servicer databases and other records at will. Servicers can’t be allowed to manage the info flow to the monitor.
b) If the monitor finds problems, s/he must be able to impose immediate penalties of a variety of strengths without going through a process that enables the servicers to appeal and object and delay. Think of the monitor as a probation officer.
c) The monitor should have a process for homeowners to file complaints, and a certain threshold of substantiated complaints should trigger enforcement action.
d) The monitor must be truly independent with the skills, experience, staffing and other resources to do the job right.
e) The monitor’s job and powers must continue into perpetuity unless the agreement is superceded by statute or regulation. This is important because homeowners are not servicers’ customers. The economic interests of the servicer do not align with homeowners, and after a deal’s expiration there’s zero reason to expect compliance to continue.
2) Servicing Standards. When the “deal” was first leaked early last year I took it apart for DailyFinance here. What was abundantly clear from the proposal was that it mostly required servicers to obey the law, including the duties of good faith and fair dealing. That is, the document mostly exposed how much of the problem is a failure to enforce existing law. The biggest addition was the idea that servicers can’t foreclose on someone they’re considering for a modification. Of course, that is also a blatantly deceptive (and therefore illegal) practice, and that’s why Massachusetts AG Martha Coakley included it in her suit against five bailed-out banks (at paragraph 142).
Beyond the very vanilla stuff in that original, “obey the law” term sheet, the settlement must force the banks to let the independent monitor’s team audit their account records. Evidence keeps surfacing that their records of who owes how much, to whom, are simply wrong far too much of the time. Consider these recent stories by Reuters and iWatch News or this one I wrote about a year ago. Or consider that servicers have been playing games with amounts borrowers owe in bankruptcy court so frequently that the court did a two year, seven step process to change the rules and force the banks to deal in good faith. (I write about the rule changes and background here, starting under “Measuring Up: The U.S. Trustees Program”.)
Bottom line: mortgage servicers will never be able to do a good job unless their databases are totally overhauled, and they’ll never do that overhaul without an independent audit. And no, I don’t mean “independent” in the OCC sense; I mean actually independent, by the settlement monitor.
What the current servicing standards are on the table isn’t clear, since we’ve not seen anything in nearly a year. It’s impossible to evaluate the terms on the table without seeing them, but unless the terms are better than that initial leak, they’re nowhere near good enough.
3) Principal Reductions
One of the oddest features of the settlement as discussed to date is the idea that the banks will be given total discretion to allocate most of the billions of dollars involved among borrowers. Several bad consequences flow from that.
First, no state can know how much it’s getting (except the rightly-rejected CA bribe). How can an AG, in good conscience, take a deal without knowing what it’s worth to his or her state? Second, structuring the deal this way enables the banks to focus on managing their balance sheets rather than providing relief to homeowners. That is, decisions about who to help and how much will have nothing to do with who needs help or how much help they need. Third, as part of that balance sheet management, the banks will be able to shift losses from themselves to pension funds. How is that just?
I call this feature of the settlement odd, because it’s completely unnecessary. Consider what happened after BP turned the Gulf of Mexico into a toxic waste dump: we made them stick $20 billion in a kitty, put Ken Feinberg in charge, and he cut checks to victims. Why isn’t that the model in this case?
Instead of letting the banks manipulate the numbers to their advantage, we should require them to cough up the full amount in actual cash, and let a fully staffed and independent special master pay down the mortgages. The special master for each state should be appointed by that state’s AG, and the banks should not have a right to object to the person chosen. More; the rule should be that the payments are applied, 100%, to principal and interest. Any outstanding fees that the servicer has applied to the account only get repaid if the servicer submits a fully documented bill to the special master.
Having a state-AG named person run a fund aimed at helping that state’s victims insures the decisions about who to help how much can be made by someone who really has homeowners’ interests at heart. Second, by forcing the banks to cough up cash, the approach is punitive, which it’s supposed to be.
4) Regardless of how the DE’s MERS lawsuit is resolved and liability for its past actions addressed, the settlement should include an agreement to stop using MERS on all loans made after the date of the settlement. We need to limit the damage.
5) The settlement has to deal with the fact that most mortgages’ documents are FUBAR. ‘Robosigning’ isn’t simply about signing documents in a funny way; it’s about creating documents the banks don’t have because they didn’t do their job right at the outset. Why are they creating the documents? So they can win foreclosure cases. That’s obstruction of justice. When you don’t have the evidence you need, you’re not supposed to just make sh-t up. But the servicers are, systematically. And it’s not like they’re doing things they have the right to do, just late. For a variety of reasons these documents are just fraudulent. They’re creating documents in the name of companies that have long since gone out of business, for example.
Bottom line: You can’t solve “robosigning” simply by slowing the process down long enough for people to review newly-minted documents before submitting them. Similarly, if the database the reviewer is checking the numbers against is wrong, the review doesn’t help either. How to resolve the FUBAR documents situation? I don’t know. All I know is that the topic has to be dealt with head on.
6) The liability waiver should be narrow. Perhaps that’s a done deal; certainly there’s considerable reporting to that effect. All I can say is 1) the text isn’t released, and 2) if the origination fraud waiver was so narrow, why were the banks willing to give CA a $15 billion bribe to sign on? What is it about California’s released liability that inspired such a big bribe?
But let’s say, ok, the waiver’s narrow. If 1 through 5 above aren’t also part of the deal, then it’s a joke; the help for homeowners is too little in terms of dollars and too ephemeral in terms of servicing improvements. So the banks aren’t getting much liability released, but homeowners also aren’t getting much help.
In yor earlier post, you had pondered that Schneiderman already had the authority to take on the banks prior to this new post and responsibility. But as US Attorney for NY, would he have the rhe reach to address matters abroad? These banks are all MNCs, and have their greedy little fingerprints all over the globe - including assets offshore waiting for a tax holiday or in the Swiss accounts of the officers.
I want to be optomistic and believe that when Obama said Jamie Dimon was smart, he was setting himself up to later point out that he wasn't smart enough to evade federal prosecutors. - that's the audacity of my hope, at least.