Sunday, March 14, 2010

FEDERAL STATUTES ENTITLE PRIVATE CITIZENS AN AWARD OF ATTORNEYS FEES IN A CIVIL ACTION SHOULD THEY PREVAIL

 Thank You So Much For Your Donations! May God Bless Every Hurting Homeowner.   Thank You Lord for the Turning Tide.  May Every Homeowner Who Reads These Words Be Blessed with a Quieted Title.  God's Will Be Done Always.  Keep the Prayers Up...and PLEASE Let Us Know How Your Are!!  We worry about your homes as if they were our own.  Every homeowner win against WELLS FARGO brings us closer to a  $1,430,000,000 goal.   WELLS FARGO's loss of $1.43B will help us feel as if we have avenged the $143,000 in our home's equity they stole from us.   We want to HELP HOMEOWNERS LOCK WELLS FARGO OUT OF ACCESSING ANY SQUARE INCH OF THEIR HOMES.  

In 2010 Quiet the Titles on $1.43B of purportedly WELLS FARGO homes...

One classs action...
A Recent California Ruling
for an
Award
for
Private Attorney General(a Pro Se Litigant)!!!!

Metropolitan News-Enterprise
Friday, Novemberer 21, 2008
Supreme Court Rules:
Attempt to Settle Not Required for ‘Private Attorney General’ Fees

 By KENNETH OFGANG, Staff Writer

 A prevailing party seeking an award of attorney fees under the “private attorney general” statute, Code of Civil Procedure Sec. 1021.5, need not necessarily show it made adequate efforts to resolve the dispute short of litigation, the state Supreme Court ruled yesterday. The justices unanimously upheld an award of more than $1.25 million to attorneys for Cristina Vasquez, vice president of the textile workers’ union UNITE.

Vasquez prevailed in an action accusing the state of violating Proposition 139, which requires that prison inmates working for joint ventures with private industry be paid prevailing wages, after officials agreed to a stipulated injunction establishing procedures designed to ensure compliance.

Vasquez’s taxpayer claim arose out of allegations that the state and a private company called CMT Blues violated the Prison Inmate Labor Initiative of 1990 because a joint venture to manufacture clothing at the Richard J. Donovan Correctional Facility in San Diego did not pay wages comparable to those paid in the private sector. Inmates allegedly were also instructed to remove and replace “Made in Honduras” labels on garments with those that read “Made in the USA.”
  
Class Action
WELLS FARGO VICTIMS ARE UNITED
YOU'VE BEEN PATIENT
IT'S TIME TO FILE
THE TIDE IS TURNING
THE INJUNCTIONS ARE PREPARED
THE MOTIONS TO SHOW CAUSE ARE READY TO SERVE
THE SUMMONS ARE IN THE HANDS OF THE PROCESS SERVERS
VICTIMS ARE STILL COMING IN, BUT I THINK IT'S TIME
START PRAYING,
YOU WILL BE COMPENSATED, VINDICATED, RECOMPENSED
RESTORED
TO A POSITION
BETTER THAN YOU COULD HAVE EVER HOPED FOR, IMAGINED, OR DREAMED.

The inmates’ claims were certified as a class action and tried without a jury, resulting in a verdict of more than $840,000. Vasquez’s taxpayer claim was tried later, but was settled mid-trial, with the amount of attorney fees, if any, left to San Diego Superior Court Judge William Pate’s discretion.
Pate concluded that Vasquez’s attorneys had devoted about $967,000 worth of time to her claim and applied a multiplier of 1.3 in reaching the final amount.

The state appealed the award, arguing among other things that Vasquez was not entitled to attorney fees because she had not engaged in a reasonable effort to settle prior to filing suit. The Third District Court of Appeal affirmed, distinguishing Graham v. DaimlerChrysler Corp. (2004) 34 Cal.4th 553, which imposed such a requirement.

The Court of Appeal noted that Graham involved an award of fees under the “catalyst” theory, which holds that a party that did not prevail in litigation may nonetheless be awarded fees under Sec. 1021.5 if the suit caused the defendant to change its behavior in a way that benefited the public or a large class of persons.

Not Catalyst Case
Vasquez’s suit was not a catalyst case, since it resulted in a stipulated injunction, and no policy reason supports extending the requirement of a reasonable settlement effort to non-catalyst cases, the Court of Appeal reasoned.

Justice Kathryn M. Werdegar, writing yesterday for the Supreme Court, said that a trial court, in exercising its discretion over whether to award fees under Sec. 1021.5, must consider “all circumstances bearing on the question whether private enforcement was necessary, including whether the party seeking fees attempted to resolve the matter before resorting to litigation,” but that there is no categorical requirement of a reasonable settlement effort in non-catalyst case.

Nothing in Graham or subsequent California cases supports imposing such a requirement, Werdegar wrote, nor is there any reason to extend the rule.

“In Graham, we simply identified a set of cases at one end of the equitable spectrum that appeared to justify a bright-line rule because, in those cases, no court-ordered change in the parties’ legal relationship exists to show that the public benefit supposedly meriting fees was caused by the plaintiff’s litigation rather than by the defendant’s voluntary action,” the justice wrote.

Werdegar went on to reject the argument that the suit should be treated as a catalyst case since it ended in settlement. “We have...never adopted the formula the state offers as the definition of a catalyst case,” the justice said.

The case was argued in the Supreme Court by San Diego attorney Martin Buchanan for the state and by Richard Berke of Santa Monica for the plaintiff. Amici included the Los Angeles County Bar Association, The Impact Fund, and the Pacific Legal Foundation for the plaintiff and the California State Association of Counties and League of California Cities for the state.
HOMEOWNERS IN CALIFORNIA
FIGHTBACK! 
REPRESENT YOURSELF, ACT AS YOUR OWN
"PRIVATE ATTORNEY GENERAL"
Code of Civil Procedure section 1021.5Entitles non-attorney's to plead for attorney's fees!
http://www.calattorneysfees.com/cases_private_attorney_general_ccp_10215/

The case is Vasquez v. State of California, 08 S.O.S. 6283.
Copyright 2008, Metropolitan News Company

Permalink
November 20, 2008

California Supreme Court Rejects Categorical Rule That Plaintiff Must Have Engaged In Reasonable Settlement Efforts In Seeking CCP Section 1021.5 Fees Under Noncatalyst Cases

Unanimous Court in Vasquez v. State of California Adopts A More Flexible Rule and Equitable Consideration of This Factor in the Noncatalyst 1021.5 Context.

In our category "Cases Under Review," we noted that the California Supreme Court had accepted review of Vasquez v. State of California, which presented the issue of whether plaintiff, in order to recover attorney's fees under Code of Civil Procedure section 1021.5 (the private attorney general statute) first had to attempt to settle the matter short of litigation in a noncatalyst case. On November 20, 2008, the Court came down with its decision in Case No. S143710, squarely answering the question "no."

Earlier, in Graham v. DaimlerChrysler Corp., 34 Cal.4th 553, 560 (2004), the California Supreme Court had held that this reasonable settlement effort was a prerequisite for a section 1021.5 fee award in a "catalyst case". In Graham, the Supreme Court held the “catalyst theory” permits a court to award attorney fees under section 1021.5 “even when litigation does not result in a judicial resolution if the defendant changes its behavior substantially because of, and and in the manner sought by, the litigation.” However, in Vasquez, the Supreme Court found nothing in either the legislative history of or policies underlying section 1021.5 to mandate an extension of the reasonable settlement effort requirement in the context of noncatalyst cases. (In Vasquez, plaintiff obtained a stipulated injunction--which is not treated as a catalyst situation.)


The Court rejected application of a categorical rule in noncatalyst cases. Instead, the lower courts have equitable discretion to weight the reasonable settlement effort factor when determining that "the necessity and financial burden of private enforcement are such as to make the award appropriate" under one of the section 1021.5 prongs. Justice Werdegar, writing on behalf of a 7-0 court, stated:
"The language of section 1021.5 is sufficiently flexible to permit courts to consider these and all other relevant circumstances in determining whether private enforcement was sufficiently necessary to justify awarding fees." (Slip Opn, at p. 8.)

Vasquez also mentioned other situations, noting that reasonable settlement efforts must be demonstrated as a fee prerequisite in FEHA catalyst cases, while no such requirement need be met in ADA cases. It similarly has a nice discussion of the distinctions between "catalyst" and "noncatalyst" cases.

YOU CAN BE YOUR OWN ATTORNEY, AND WIN ATTORNEY'S FEES! 
YES, THE AMOUNT THE OTHER SIDE WOULD HAVE WON, A REASONABLE AMOUNT.
 HAVE YOU BEEN ABLE TO LET GO, MOVE ON? YES? GOD BLESS YOU.
NO, LET GOD HELP YOU. PRAY. LISTEN. WHAT DOES HE SAY?

COURT OF THE U.S. – RULES Part VII. Practice and Procedure Rule 39. Proceedings In Forma Pauperis. The courts provide in propria persona parties wide latitude when construing their pleadings and papers. When interpreting pro se papers, the Court should use common sense to determine what relief the party desires. Defendant has the right to submit in propria persona briefs on appeal, even though they may be in artfully drawn but the court can reasonably read and understand them. See, Vega v. Johnson, 149 F.3d 354 (5th Cir.1998).Acting Private Attorney General: PJ Stewart, under 42 U.S.C. § 2000a–3, 33 U.S.C. 1365, 18 USC § 3283, 42U.S.C § 1983, 28 U.S.C. § 1343, The term private attorney general refers private citizens who in any civil or criminal court proceeding, is acting on behalf of that person’s rights and equal protection under the law. The private attorney general is entitled to recover attorney’s fees if he or she prevails.

ARMING
ATTORNEYS
and PRIVATE ATTORNEY GENERALS
WITH THE AMMO TO WIN!
Posted on March 14, 2010
by Neil Garfield

Winning Strategies Require Attorneys Have: 
  1. Leverage of a credible threat 
  2. Issues of fact that shift or heighten the burden of proof to the foreclosing party
  3. Evidence vs Allegations
  4. Understanding of your Opponent – Right hand isn’t often talking to the Left hand
  5. Guns with only one bullet (e.g. produce the note) are for Russian Roulette
  6. You ned a full magazine in case you misfire a couple rounds
  7. KISS – Keep it Simple Stupid…so the Judge can Understand
  8.  Difference between a “Loan Audit” and Mortgage Analysis
  9. Aessing Lender Compliance at Origination
  10. It’s all about Disclosure Requirements
  11. How to Analyze and Identify Material TILA RESPA HOEPA Violations Yourself
  12. Rescission: What it is and what it isn’t
  13. Right ways and Wrong ways to apply TILA and other Loan Compliance Findings
  14. Evidence or Characteristics of “Predatory” Lending
  15. Using the Qualified Written Request (QWR)
  16. Requirement to Disclose the True Owner
  17. What Forensic Mortgage Analysis uncovers that the “canned TILA audit” doesn’t
  18. Securitization for Dummies
  19. Public Domain Evidence – SEC filings and What They Can Reveal
  20. Important Questions SEC Filings Don’t Reveal That Should be Answered
  21. What a periodic distribution report to the Certificate holders can determine
Wells Fargo to Repurchase
$1.4 Billion of Securities:
WHAT THAT MEANS TO YOU

 Posted on November 19, 2009
by Neil Garfield

You can use this information by establishing “probable cause” in the mind of the Judge or jury right off the bat — we know they lied to investors, are we now supposed to believe they told the truth to the homeowners?

This is the kind of news article buried deep into a newspaper or far down on the list of on-line articles that leaves everyone — homeowners, attorneys, judges, legislators and regulators — in the dark. Wells Fargo is settling one of many claims that it lied to investors about the mortgage backed securities they bought which funded your loan and which filled the pockets of Wall Street “innovators” for years. It doesn’t actually tell us what they lied about — you’ll need to look up the complaint (which I hope someone will do and send to me in pdf format) but it does say that those investors are now paid off in full and that Wells Fargo is buying back what they sold.

Now Wells Fargo will attempt to use that purchase as proof that it is the “INVESTOR” ignoring the ill-gotten gains that preceded it, and attempting to establish itself as the holder in due course, long after the securities were in default, long after the underlying asset mortgages were in default, and long after Wells Fargo received payoffs in credit default swaps that easily cover what they paid the investors and then some.

The point here is that the shell game continues. The regulators are not sophisticated or motivated enough to actually express this for what it is. Even the media gets totally confused. Instead of saying that many loans were paid off or sold back to Wells Fargo for $1.4 billion, it says something about “auction rate securities” which means nothing to practically everyone. What this REALLY means is that you have a defendant (actually several of them — see below) who has actually and demonstrably committed fraud as part of the securitization scheme that funded the financial loan products sold to homeowners — except that so far everyone is concentrating on the fraud on investors. Why is that? The little guy who was lied to, abused and shaken by this ordeal doesn’t matter. It’s just the people with the money that count. You can use this information by establishing “probable cause” in the mind of the Judge or jury right off the bat — we know they lied to investors, are we now supposed to believe they told the truth to the homeowners?

Monday, March 8, 2010

HOMEOWNER'S POTENTIAL FOR VICTORY IS NOW ENORMOUS

Wall Street vs. Main Street:
Courts Beginning to Side
 in Favor of
 Foreclosed Property Owners

By George W. Mantor

RISMEDIA, October 27, 2009—Agents involved in foreclosures and short sales may need to begin to disclose the possibility of serious property transfer defects associated with these types of lender controlled sales.

If recent court decisions are any indication, we could be headed for an explosion of litigation in this area.

And now, Massachusetts Courts have revealed the possibility that unlawful foreclosures, dating back to 1989, might be invalidated and that buyers of foreclosed properties and short sales may have clouded titles.

The implications are enormous for title companies, bankruptcy attorneys, real estate agents, those facing foreclosure, and those who have lost their homes.

The problem stems from the collision of two worlds. It illustrates what can happen when the new world fails to acknowledge or understand the old. It is change that takes place without the cooperation of all affected parties.

Real property law has an ancient tradition. But, its laws and their purpose are not always apparent to those who want to change those traditions to benefit themselves.

In the case of maintaining a public chain of title to real property, it was thought to be essential and generally required by the law.

For hundreds of years, no one ever thought of any reason to change it. It was thought to be part of the public good.

That is, until Wall Street saw the money making potential in credit derivatives.

Credit derivatives are packages of debts such as car loans, student loans, credit card debts, and mortgage loans to name a few. These are collected, rated according to their risk, and sold to investors around the world.

One small problem; if you are going to bundle mortgages from every county in the country, you would have to physically send someone to every county recorder’s office on multiple occasions and pay multiple recording fees. It was costly and cumbersome to those responsible for affecting the recordings.

Their solution? Stop recording the assignments in public and track them instead in an electronic data base that the major lenders would operate through a cooperative entity. That entity is known as Mortgage Electronic Registration Systems (MERS). In my opinion, not only did it save them a fortune in county fees and manpower, it turned out to be a cash cow.

Well, good for them, right? They figured out how to bring technology to the process and were handsomely rewarded. Never mind that the cost of maintaining a county recording system is paid, in part, by the recording revenue. They still have to maintain the apparatus, but now they aren’t receiving the revenue intended to maintain the system. Of course, this comes at a time when many counties are struggling to provide necessary services to their residents.

But, as with many new ideas, there are unintended consequences that are now coming to light as state after state are enforcing basic property rights. Consider these cases:

Massachusetts
On October 14, 2009, Judge Keith Long of the Massachusetts Land Court said in his ruling, “The issues in this case are not merely problems with paperwork or a matter of dotting i’s and crossing t’s. Instead they lie at the heart of the protections given to homeowners and borrowers by the Massachusetts legislature.”

He was referring to the industry practice of trading notes endorsed in blank, in direct violation of securities law. Here is what he said on that point; “The blank mortgage assignments they possessed transferred nothing…in Massachusetts, a mortgage is a conveyance of land. Nothing is conveyed unless and until it is validly conveyed. The various agreements between the securitization entities stating that each had a right to an assignment of the mortgage are not themselves an assignment and they are certainly not in recordable form.”

Two years earlier, Judge Rosenthal in re Schwartz, found that there was no evidence that the note itself was assigned and no evidence as to who the current holder might be.

Kansas
On August 28, 2009, Judge Eric S. Rosen of the Kansas Supreme Court likened MERS to a “straw man” and not a party of interest with the right to foreclose.

“Indeed, in the event that a mortgage loan somehow separates interests of the note and the deed of trust, with the deed of trust lying with some independent entity, the mortgage may become unenforceable. The practical effect of splitting the deed of trust from the promissory note is to make it impossible for the holder of the note to foreclose, unless the holder of the deed of trust is the agent of the holder of the note. Without the agency relationship, the person holding only the note lacks the power to foreclose in the event of a default. The person holding only the deed of trust will never experience a default because only the holder of the note is entitled to payment of the underlying obligation. The mortgage loan becomes ineffectual when the note holder did not hold the deed of trust.”

California
On October 21, 2008, Judge Samuel L. Bufford noted in his ruling that California codified the principal in 1872 in Carpenter v. Longan: “Given that ‘the debt is the principal thing and the mortgage an accessory,’ the Supreme Court reasoned that as a corollary, ‘the mortgage can have no separate existence. An assignment of the note carries the mortgage with it, while an assignment of the latter alone is a nullity.”

Nevada
On August 19th, 2008, Judge Linda B. Riegle concluded, “There is no evidence that the named nominee is entitled to enforce the note or that MERS is the agent of the note’s holder. Indeed, the evidence is to the contrary, the note has been sold, and the named nominee no longer has any interest in the note.”

Arkansas
On March 19, 2009 the Supreme Court of Arkansas found that MERS was not the beneficiary under the deed of trust, although so designated in the deed of trust, because it did not receive the payments on the underlying debt.
Ohio
On October 31, 2007, U.S. District Judge Christopher Boyko dismissed 14 foreclosure actions and delivered a strong admonishment in a footnote:

“Plaintiff’s ‘Judge, you just don’t understand how things work,’ argument reveals a condescending mindset and quasi-monopolistic system where financial institutions have traditionally controlled, and still control, the foreclosure process…There is no doubt that every decision made by a financial institution in the foreclosure is driven by money.”

When you consider the origin of this problem, it is hard to disagree. If the foreclosing entity didn’t loan the money, the original note was sold, the location of the note is unknown, and it isn’t even clear what would happen to the proceeds of the eventual sale of the property to a new owner.

Until recently, MERS had succeeded in most foreclosure actions. In non judicial foreclosure states like California, there is no judicial review of the elements of a foreclosure. Unless the borrower files for bankruptcy or brings a law suit against MERS alleging RESPA or TILA violations, there is no opportunity for the borrower to challenge the foreclosure.

In judicial foreclosure states, there is a law suit brought by the party entitled to payment on the defaulted loan. Not the trust, but the actual possessor in due course of the original note. It’s part judicial procedure, part uniform commercial code and part ancient property law.

But, the securitization business is so complicated, intentionally so, that defendants, most of their legal representation, and the judges rarely considered the consequences to the real parties in interest. This will continue until enough people understand the importance of the actual note and its relationship to the property.

I believe many homes have been unlawfully foreclosed by entities not entitled to anything. The former owners of these homes have rights that will need to be addressed.

People who applied for mortgage modifications and received them may have gotten approval from an unwitting bank employee with no authority to change the underlying terms of the securities in the pools.

Many people bought these homes and have potential future claims. If there is a cloud on title, the new owner is at risk of being unable to sell or encumber the property. If the foreclosure were unlawful, the borrower is entitled to their property. And, there is a very real possibility that the true holder of the actual note, once and if ever this mess is sorted out, could come forward with the actual note.

It isn’t important to only those in foreclosure. Those seeking loan modifications, potential buyers of short sales and foreclosures and those acting in a fiduciary capacity on their behalf, may soon be demanding, “Show me the note.”

About the author: George W. Mantor is known as “The Real Estate Professor” for his wealth building formula, Lx2+(U²)xTFP=$? and consumer education efforts. During a career that has spanned more than three decades, he has amassed experience in new home and resale residential real estate, resort marketing, and commercial and investment property. He is currently the founder and president of The Associates Financial Group, a real estate consulting firm.

Sunday, March 7, 2010

AMEND NUMBER ONE TO POOLING AND SERVICING AGREEMENT

AMEND NUMBER ONE TO POOLING AND SERVICING AGREEMENT

Wells Fargo's reserve for repurchases, as of Dec. 31, totaled $1 billion, up from $589 million a year earlier. (AND THEIR GOING TO NEED EVERY SINGLE PENNY!!!)

Lenders Face Headwinds
As Mortgage Buybacks Escalate
By Aparajita Saha-Bubna, Of DOW JONES NEWSWIRES

Lenders such as Bank of America Corp. (BAC), J.P. Morgan Chase & Co. (JPM), Wells Fargo & Co. (WFC) and Citigroup Inc. (C) will brave stiff headwinds this year as they face increasing demands to buy back defectively underwritten mortgages.

Lenders bought back about $20 billion of loans with faulty underwriting in 2009, according to Barclays Capital estimates, writing off as much half of this amount as the loans were delinquent. Banks say mortgage buybacks could be a problem for earnings this year as well.

The vast majority of mortgages being put back comes from Fannie Mae (FNM) and Freddie Mac (FRE), according to Barclays and the banks' 10-K filings, as the mortgage finance giants step up efforts to collect on bad loans.

When these banks are forced to buy back souring loans, they typically do so at a loss. This means higher loss reserves and continued fallout from the housing crisis. For the lenders, which are among the largest sellers of mortgages to Fannie and Freddie, the repurchases wipe out a chunk of the income they earned in fees from making these loans.

"Mortgage repurchases should have a considerable impact on banks," said Ajay Rajadhyaksha, head of U.S. fixed-income and securitized strategy at Barclays Capital. "The lenders taking these loans back often have to write them down 40- 50 cents on the dollar." Banks bought back mortgages of about $15 billion through the first three quarters of 2009, according to Barclays data.

For instance, Wells Fargo bought back mortgages with balances of $1.3 billion in 2009. About three-fourths of repurchases were conforming loans from Fannie and Freddie. It incurred losses of $514 million on these repurchases. In 2008, it bought back $426 million of loans, while losses stemming from repurchases totaled $251 million.

Banks are already on the hook for bad mortgages residing on their books. But investors such as Fannie and Freddie are seeking to hold banks accountable as well for what they say are improperly underwritten mortgages sold to them in the past.

In 2009, Freddie Mac put back about $4.1 billion of single-family mortgages to lenders, more than double the $1.8 billion in 2008, according to its 10-K filing. In addition, Freddie's mortgage repurchase requests outstanding totaled $4 billion, as of Dec. 31. Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae don't lend directly to consumers, but buy or guarantee home mortgages from lenders.

A Fannie Mae spokesman said data on loans put back in 2009 weren't available. In 2008, Fannie bounced back roughly a quarter of the loans on 94,652 real- estate-owned, or REO, properties it reclaimed after foreclosure. In 2009, Fannie acquired 145,617 REO properties.

"Borrowers, the mortgage industry and taxpayers are all well served when Fannie Mae exercises its rights to require lenders to repurchase loans that do not meet Fannie Mae's underwriting standards," Terry Edwards, an executive vice president at Fannie, said in a statement. Fannie and Freddie are controlled by the U.S. government, which has bailed them out to the tune of $126.9 billion.

To be sure, lenders are putting up a fight. Addressing the issue of mortgage repurchases at a conference in February, Barbara Desoer, president of Bank of America's mortgage business, said, "We continue to fight the battle at a loan- by-loan level." As of Dec. 31, nearly 30%, or $1.1 billion, of Freddie's unfulfilled repurchase requests were outstanding for more than 90 days.

In most cases, investors holding these loans can force the lender to take the mortgages back, and recover the unpaid principal on them, if they were underwritten improperly. For instance, lenders would have to buy back loans from investors if borrowers lied about their income or misstated that the property is their primary residence. Other reasons a loan may be put back: a fraudulent home appraisal or inadequate documentation.

In 2009, Bank of America bought back first-lien mortgages with balances of $ 1.5 billion tied to faulty underwriting, compared with $448 million in 2008; expenses related to repurchases jumped to $1.9 billion last year from $246 million in 2008. The buybacks were "predominantly" loans from Fannie and Freddie, said a spokesman.

J.P. Morgan had $1.7 billion, as of Dec. 31, set aside to meet repurchase claims from investors, compared with $1.1 billion a year earlier. The company last month said repurchase demand "remains elevated" at around $1 billion each quarter. It said loan repurchase claims are resolved through a review process with Fannie and Freddie within about two to three years.

Wells Fargo's reserve for repurchases, as of Dec. 31, totaled $1 billion, up from $589 million a year earlier.

Citigroup's repurchase reserve held a balance of $482 million, as of Dec. 31, up from $75 million a year earlier, according to its 10-K filing. A Citigroup spokesman declined to comment.

Inadequate mortgage repurchase reserves spelled the end for lender New Century Financial in 2007. At the time, its underreserving allowed the lender to overstate its financial reports.

-By Aparajita Saha-Bubna, Dow Jones Newswires; 617-654-6729; aparajita.saha- bubna@dowjones.com

HOMEOWNERS ARE FORCED FROM THEIR HOMES THEN BANKS WALK AWAY

DIRTY DEEDS
by Michael Todd


The mortgage crisis has blighted the landscape with boarded-up houses. Now a few cities are holding giant lenders accountable for what foreclosure leaves behind. 

On Dec. 17 in a windowless Buffalo courtroom, Cindy T. Cooper, a prosecutor for the city, buzzes among a dozen men in suits, cutting deals. "You've got to unboard [the house], go in, and clean it out," she tells one. "If all the repairs are done quickly, I wouldn't ask for any fines." To another, she says, "the gutters weren't done right," and asks to see receipts for the work. It's "Bank Day" in Judge Henry J. Nowak's housing courtroom, more typically a venue where landlords and tenants duke it out over evictions and back rent. Instead, Cooper is asking lawyers for CitiFinancial (C), JPMorgan Chase (JPM), and Countrywide Financial (CFC) to fix problems like peeling paint, broken masonry, and overgrown or trash-filled yards at houses the city says the banks are responsible for maintaining. It may be surprising to find these financial-services giants hauled before this obscure local tribunal. In fact, Cooper and Nowak are at the forefront of a pioneering effort to deal with a vexing problem: the surging number of vacant and abandoned homes resulting from the mortgage market meltdown. The vacancies occur when lenders bring foreclosure suits against delinquent borrowers. Mere notice that such an action might be filed often sends residents packing. In Buffalo and other Rust Belt cities, the problem has been particularly acute, because in many cases banks are abandoning the houses, too, after determining that their value is so low that it's not worth laying claim to them. When city officials try to hold someone responsible for dilapidated properties, they often find the homeowner and bank pointing fingers at each other. Indeed, the houses fall into a kind of legal limbo that Cleveland housing attorney Kermit J. Lind calls "toxic title". While formal ownership remains with a borrower who has fled, the bank retains its lien on the property. That opens up a dispute over who is responsible for taxes and maintenance. Even when lenders do complete the foreclosure, they may walk away from the property, leaving it to be taken by a city for unpaid taxes, a process that can take years. Orphaned properties quickly fall into disrepair, the deterioration sometimes hastened by vandals who trash the interiors, lighting fires and ripping out wiring and pipes to sell for scrap. Squatters or drug dealers may move in.

The impact goes far beyond the defaulting homeowner, as neighbors and entire communities confront a spreading blight. Vacant residences (BusinessWeek, 1/4/08) deprive cities of tax revenue and can cost them thousands to maintain. A 2001 Temple University study in Philadelphia found that simply being within 150 feet of an abandoned property knocked $7,600 off a home's value.

In Buffalo, prosecutor Cooper is bringing lenders before Judge Nowak to hold them accountable. Wielding the threat of liens, which can hold up the lenders' other real estate transactions, she aims to make banks keep foreclosed homes in good condition until a buyer can be found. As an alternative, Cooper or Nowak may try to get lenders to donate properties to community groups or to pay for demolition when houses are beyond repair. "At least in Buffalo," says Cooper, "the days are gone when you can do a foreclosure and walk away without taking care of the property."

Those charged with violations by Cooper include participants all along the complex mortgage-industry food chain, from loan originators to servicers to the Wall Street trusts that buy up the vast majority of home loans and then securitize them. A similar initiative is under way in Cleveland, where Judge Raymond L. Pianka puts lenders on trial in absentia when they fail to respond to charges.

Even places with high property values, like Chula Vista, Calif., a San Diego suburb, are taking steps to avoid the neglect that can occur during lengthy foreclosures. "It seems like a number of the lenders aren't even doing things that are in their own best interest to preserve the asset," says Pianka—a problem he attributes to the fragmented nature of the business. "It's not an address. It's not a property. It's just a loan number," he says. "So they'll push a button in San Francisco, and it will set things in motion to do things with [a] property that don't even make sense."


SPREADING THE PAIN

The proceedings in Pianka's and Nowak's courtrooms offer a sobering reminder that underlying the attenuated ownership and esoteric products spun out of mortgages are actual buildings, some with leaky roofs or broken porch railings. The industry denies responsibility for properties to which it has not taken title. "The notion that a mortgage company has an obligation to make repairs on a property that it doesn't even own is very hard to comprehend," says Marco Cercone, a Buffalo attorney who represents a range of lenders before Nowak in the courtroom. Cooper says that banks and other financial firms once extolled houses as the best possible collateral for a loan. Now they're stuck with that collateral, and they don't like it.

If there ever is a national response to the messy legacy left by foreclosures, it might include something like the Buffalo system, which seeks to take action before the presence of abandoned houses hurts entire neighborhoods and which spreads the pain among many players. "We're kind of a crystal ball into what might happen" elsewhere, Cooper says.

Lenders may rue the day the State University of New York at Buffalo admitted Cooper to pursue a PhD in sociology and a law degree. The subject of her doctoral thesis, submitted in December, 2006: the role of banks in residential abandonment and why they should be accountable for property-code violations. The fourth-generation Californian says she quickly became attached to Buffalo for its history and architecture. Now 33, Cooper and her husband are rehabilitating a house that she bought after getting an IRS tax lien removed from the property. "My passion for this work is because I love this town," she says.

While researching her thesis, Cooper interned for Judge Nowak. Tall, soft-spoken, and unfailingly courteous, the judge, 39, began holding Bank Day earlier this year and schedules it once a month. The civility of the proceedings and the large number of bank lawyers in attendance belie a noteworthy fact: They are there under coercion. A few years ago, Nowak says, "the city became increasingly frustrated with the banks' role" in contributing to Buffalo's abandoned-property problem. (Estimates put the number of abandoned homes in the city at between 5,000 and 10,000.) In 2004, New York State amended the definition of "owner" in its property maintenance code to include not just titleholders but others who had "control" over a premises.

While the statute makes no reference to lenders, Nowak contends that the letters banks send to defaulting homeowners threatening to boot them from their houses show that they have begun to "assert some measure of control." On this premise, Nowak says, Buffalo began contacting banks "en masse" about foreclosed properties, but "a lot of times we'd just be rebuffed and ignored."

Cooper, as an intern, suggested a tactic that the judge adopted. When banks ignored summonses for code violations, Nowak began entering default judgments against them and imposing the maximum fine, which can reach $10,000 to $15,000. For a big bank, that's not much. The real pain comes because the fines give the city a lien that impedes the banks' ability to buy or sell other properties in the area. In addition, when lenders come to his court to get residents evicted from a particular property, Nowak refuses to grant the request until the bank addresses violations outstanding on other properties. Judge Pianka employs similar tactics in Cleveland. On Dec. 10, for example, he assessed a $50,000 fine against an absentee defendant, Mortgage Lenders Network USA, for 21 code violations at a home.

Even far from the Rust Belt, in places where empty houses retain significant value, the lending industry seems to have trouble preserving its collateral when homes are abandoned during foreclosure. In Chula Vista, a number of houses have been trashed by college students who have held parties in the vacant properties. In other cases, pillagers pull up in rental trucks to cart away cabinets, wood flooring, and fixtures stripped from the homes. But in October, an ordinance went into effect requiring lenders to register and maintain houses that have been abandoned during foreclosure.

Compliance, says Chula Vista code enforcement manager Doug Leeper, has been spotty. "What I need them to do is keep the water on and keep the lawn green," he says, noting that the first sign of abandonment is often a yard that has turned brown and a pool that has gone murky green.

That slide into decrepitude is exactly what Cooper is trying to head off in Buffalo. In February, she joined the city's law department, where one of her duties is prosecuting banks. She and Nowak each say their main objective is not collecting fines but bringing banks to the table to try to find constructive solutions for dealing with abandoned property. That doesn't mean borrowers are off the hook. Cooper typically charges both borrowers and lenders, and Nowak may fine homeowners or sentence them to community service. "Can both be responsible?" asks Cooper. "Absolutely."

The approach in Buffalo is paying dividends. In a case on Dec. 17, attorney Cercone addressed the status of a house that had gone into foreclosure in 2006. Cercone was representing JPMorgan Chase and Ocwen Loan Servicing (which in turn were representatives of a securitized trust that had purchased the mortgage). Cercone submitted an affidavit showing that Ocwen, which had been cited for violations in December, 2006, had spent $30,000 to repair the property, including scraping lead paint from the entire house. In September, the affidavit notes, JP Morgan Chase sold the property at a loss of $19,500, not including the cost of repairs. "The bank in this case dealt with the property as well as could be done under the circumstances," Nowak said from the bench, and he agreed not to impose any fines.

TORTUOUS TRAILS
Still, even with novel and aggressive tactics, the path to resolution for many properties in Buffalo can be tortuous and protracted. A house at 1941 Niagara St.—one of dozens of properties that Cooper examined as a graduate studenthas yet to see its final chapter, though it may be close.

In 1998, Elizabeth M. Manuel obtained a $34,500 mortgage on the property from IMC Mortgage (since acquired by Citibank). By 2002, the loan had been sold into a securitization trust administered by Chase Manhattan (now JPMorgan Chase) as trustee. It also went into default, and Chase began foreclosure proceedings. In a court filing, Manuel (who could not be located for comment) said she left the home while the foreclosure action was pending. More than five years later, though, the title remains in her name. The house, although still standing, has become a fire-gutted wreck.

In May 2007, Nowak issued a default judgment against Chase for $9,000. But these cases can be notoriously difficult to untangle. Thomas A. Kelly, a spokesman for the bank, notes that Chase sold its trustee business to the Bank of New York Mellon (BK) in October, 2006, and couldn't locate anyone at Chase able to comment. But he reiterates the industry view that Chase can't be held responsible for maintaining a property it never owned. He acknowledges that if a home didn't seem worth taking as collateral, the bank may have made a decision to "just walk away."

The value of 1941 Niagara, estimate city assessors, is $4,500, of which $4,300 represents the value of the land. The home, Cooper says, is slated for "imminent" demolition.

Orey covers corporations for BusinessWeek .

GOD BLESS EVERY HOMEOWNER WHO FIGHTS TO KEEP THE AMERICAN DREAM ALIVE

VICTORIOUS HOMEOWNERS
DONATE THEIR PRECIOUS DOLLARS
TO HELP OTHERS
FIGHT PRETENDER LENDERS
FROM STEALING HOMES




HELP US HELP KEEP
HOMEOWNERS
IN THEIR HOMES!
PayPal Customer Service Number:

1-888-221-1161

Or send money order payable to:

Homeowners
Helping
Homeowners!

Foreclosure Self Help
33605 W. 88th Street
De Soto, KS 66006
913-220-1284
913-273-1448 FAX

DO YOU NEED HELP TO AVOID FORECLOSURE?

If you would like to receive information on how you might avoid the foreclosure of your home, please e-mail me your name, address, and phone number. Someone from our office will be in touch right away to assist you. With Warm Regards, Kelly L. Hansen, HOMEOWNERS HELPING HOMEOWNERS, ctsmyhon@yahoo.com
Be happy, healthy and prosperous, but most of all, be blessed.
Kelly L. Hansen's photo.

Kelly L. Hansen


Jurisdictionary® just click on the link
Make Sure Your Attorney Is Working For You!
Kelly L. Hansen
HOMEOWNERS HELPING HOMEOWNERS FOUNDATION
33605 W. 88th Street
De Soto, KS 66018
913-269-0399 Phone
888-881-2349 Fax
MORTGAGE FRAUD VICTIMS
ARE YOU A VICTIM OF MORTGAGE FRAUD?


PLEASE DONATE TO HELP HOMEOWNERS!